Google
Web         Gaudiya Discussions
Gaudiya Discussions Archive » PHILOSOPHY AND THEOLOGY
Discussions on the doctrines of Gaudiya Vaishnavism. Please place practical questions under the Miscellaneous forum and set this aside for the more theoretical side of it.

eternally conditioned souls - who and what was i before?



TarunGovindadas - Sun, 23 Jan 2005 17:21:48 +0530
Radhe Radhe!

based on Madhavaji´s very eloquent essay about the nature of the soul,
i came across some thoughts and some questions.

the following scenario:

John McBaddha, an eternally conditioned soul, comes into contact with Krishna through his devotees.

QUOTE
“Roaming about in the universe, by the grace of guru and the Lord a fortunate living entity receives the seed of the creeper of devotion.”


so, after some years or whatever time he receives the seed and gets first harinama-initiation and then later on diksha-initiation.
now, by the mercy of Sri Gurudeva, the svarupa-sakti of the Lord will be put in the heart of the eternally conditioned soul and thus his body will become suitable for devotional service. the body will become spiritualized.

again later on, Sri Gurudeva rewards the faithful sadhaka with siddha-pranali and the sadhaka gets to know his eternal form, for example as a manjari.

so, now the sadhaka has the chance to "turn himself" (merge) more and more into this manjari-svarupa in accordance to his or her absorption during bhajan.

finally

QUOTE
The natural conclusion is that at the time of perfection, the mukta-jiva unites with a particular parsada-deha (associate-body), a manifestation of the Lord’s antaranga-sakti in the spiritual world, especially reserved for him.

This particular form of antaranga-sakti, existing eternally in the spiritual world, is known as the specific nitya-siddha manifestation which descends into the heart of the sadhaka who has become purified through the process of sadhana. The original qualities of sat, cit and ananda which are present in this siddha-body are also experienced in accordance with the siddha-avesa (absorption in the perfected form one aspires to attain) of the sadhaka prior to siddhi.


so, the formerly beginninglessly conditioned soul has reached perfection.

since these qualities of the siddha-deha (sat-cit-ananda) are apparently not inherent in the mukta-jiva, the mukta-jiva must be of other qualities.

what then is the nature of the mukta-jivas?
shastra proclaims that all jivas are servants of the Lord.
what is the mukta-jiva´s form prior to the "coming-in-contact" with the sad-guru and prior to becoming acquainted with his/her eternal svarupa?

QUOTE
In other words, the seed-like jiva does not evolve from a glowing spiritual spark into a siddha-deha. This siddha-deha is not something which is manufactured and which evolves or transforms over time. It is an eternal reality manifested by the antaranga-sakti of Bhagavan, not a product of tatastha-sakti.


are the mukta-jivas atomic particles endowed with individual consciousness, beginninglessly in maya?

what does it mean that the body is inherent in the jiva?

QUOTE
The body is not inherent in the jiva, but is given in accordance with the way in which he is attracted to serve the Lord.

Is the jiva bound to acquire a certain svarupa which is latent within it, or is the destination of the jiva influenced by association?


so before we are something vaque like a subtle form (particle/seed/ray) and after we received the grace of Sri Guru (diksha, siddha-deha) we have an eternal form according to our spiritual desires?


Sri Gurudeva in his meditation goes to the form of the Lord as the All-Powerful Guru and this form of Krishna then tells Sri Gurudeva about the svarupa suitable for the mukta-jiva.
does that mean that Krishna already knows the eternal form of every mukta-jiva?
(especially reserved for him ?)

how does this work, considering the points from above...

please help.

sorry for causing any inconvenience.

Radhe Syam
Tarunji

biggrin.gif biggrin.gif
Madhava - Sun, 23 Jan 2005 18:22:38 +0530
Some notes on the above.

1. Regarding sat-cit-ananda in the jiva, I don't believe we can say that that is not there in the jiva. However, it is highly debatable whether the manifestations of sat, cit and ananda known as sandhini, samvit and hladini respectively -- all aspects of antaranga-shakti -- are present in the baddha-jiva, who is tatastha-sakti-prakasa. As far as my studies go, they are not.

2. That an inherent svarupa does not automatically manifest when the layers of material contamination are washed away is proven by the fact that many mukta-jivas merely merge in the formless Brahman. How would that be possible if the svarupa would automatically manifest?

3. Is our svarupa predetermined? Our svarupa is determined by the wish of Sri Krishna. He is free to hold the same opinion forever, and he is free to change his mind as well. And even if we have a latent, fixed svarupa, he is free to change that as well, whatever suits his fancy.
TarunGovindadas - Sun, 23 Jan 2005 18:42:34 +0530
QUOTE
2. That an inherent svarupa does not automatically manifest when the layers of material contamination are washed away is proven by the fact that many mukta-jivas merely merge in the formless Brahman. How would that be possible if the svarupa would automatically manifest?


Radhe Radhe!

thanks. very good and interesting point.

but again, can we speak of a "form" (svarupa) of a mukta-jiva?
so many people use so many terms:
seed, spark, particle, ray,...

blink.gif



QUOTE
1. Regarding sat-cit-ananda in the jiva, I don't believe we can say that that is not there in the jiva. However, it is highly debatable whether the manifestations of sat, cit and ananda known as sandhini, samvit and hladini respectively -- all aspects of antaranga-shakti -- are present in the baddha-jiva, who is tatastha-sakti-prakasa. As far as my studies


understood.