Google
Web         Gaudiya Discussions
Gaudiya Discussions Archive » DEVOTIONAL PRACTICES
Discussions specifically related with the various aspects of practice of bhakti-sadhana in Gaudiya Vaishnavism.

Has anyone here experienced their svarupa? -



gopidust - Wed, 11 Aug 2004 22:21:57 +0530
rolleyes.gif When I went to Vrndavana I experienced little pieces of ecstacy here and there. I don't want to be specific but basically even though I am fallen I acted in manjari-bhava at times and I am wondering did anybody else in here experience anything else like this? I did not even realise this had happened until later when I left Vrndavana and thought about the things that had happened to me. The things I did were definately real and not planned at all. If I get too specific and someone was there at the time I might get recognised so I don't want to get into details right now about myself but I would love to hear about the experiences of other devotees. unsure.gif
Jagat - Wed, 11 Aug 2004 22:39:25 +0530

Apana bhajana kathA, na kohibo jathA tathA
ihAte hoibo sAvadhAna |
nA koriho keho roSa, nA loiho keho doSa,
praNamahu bhaktera caraNa ||

I won't divulge the intimate aspects of my bhajan here and there,
but will remain very careful in such matters.
Please don't be angry or find fault with me.
I bow down to all the bhaktas.
(Prema-bhakti-candrika 119)

Why?

premA dvayo rasikayor ayi dIpa eva
hRd-veSma bhAsayati nizcalam eva bhAti |
dvArAd ayaM vadanatas tu bahiSkRtaz cen
nirvAti zIghram athavA laghutAm upaiti ||

Love’s candle burns bright in the lovers' hearts
To set aglow those chambers' darkest parts;
If one should bring it out the verbal door,
Pride’s wind will blow and it shall glow no more.
(Prema-samputa)
anuraag - Thu, 12 Aug 2004 00:05:46 +0530
gopanIyaM prayatnena
yathA ratna-karaNDakam |
kasyacin naiva vaktavyaM
kula-strI-surataM yathA ||


(Hatha-yoga-pradipika 2.9)

With great effort, keep all these devotional emotions
hidden like a chest of precious stones. rolleyes.gif
Do not talk about them to anyone, whistling.gif
just as a high-class lady would not talk about
her intimate amorous experience to others. blush.gif


Jaya Sri Radhey!
Madhava - Thu, 12 Aug 2004 05:34:35 +0530
While we're on this theme (and note: without commenting on the first post), quoting from Sri Anantadas Babaji Maharaja's Makaranda-kana commentary on Sri Rupa's Utkalika-vallari:

prapadya vRndAvana madhyam ekaH
krozann asAv utkalikAkulAtmA |
udghATayAmi jvalataH kaThorAM
bASpasya mudrAM hRdi mudritasya || 1 ||

"Having surrendered to Sri Vrindavan, a certain longing and disturbed soul cries, opening his severly burning heart, showing you the marks of my tears therein."

The words hRdi mudritasya jvalataH bASpasya mean that just as a powerful steam-engine is able to move a big train with mere compressed stream, the power generated by compressing the urge of love within the heart is able to move the engine of the body rapidly, swiftly arriving at the lotus feet of the beloved deity. Therefore, grave devotees want to hide their love within the baskets of their hearts.

The mahAjanas instruct: rAkho prema hRdaye bhariyA - "Hide the prema within your heart!" Devotees who are weak-hearted and neophytes who desire distiction may cry loudly, roll around and throw their arms and legs around when there is a kIrtana going on, thus destroying the sacred Tulasi-plant or hitting nearby saintly devotees. However, they merely stop the sincere devotees from relishing the kIrtana, thus committing offences.

Ordinary people may be impressed by such a show, but the true saints take distance from such performances. They try to keep the stema of live within their hearts in order to increase the power of their love, and they will certainly gain even more love in this way -- of this, there is no doubt!

If the feeble sprouts of love we have acquired are vented out into all directions, we will feel all empty, and our cherished secrets, the driving force behind our inspiration, will fade away. Therefore people tend to be shy in sharing their intimate spiritual experiences, particularly in their respective svarUpas, and will often even just outright deny having any such experiences to avoid the prestige. If ever, such issues are to be discussed in a closed circle of friends, but not in public.

This brings us to a related, interesting question: how much do we disclose in a public forum, and of what nature are those things that we may disclose in the open?
Talasiga - Thu, 12 Aug 2004 15:50:30 +0530
QUOTE (gopidust @ Aug 11 2004, 04:51 PM)
rolleyes.gif When I went to Vrndavana I experienced little pieces of ecstacy here and there. I don't want to be specific but basically even though I am fallen I acted in manjari-bhava at times and I am wondering did anybody else in here experience anything else like this? I did not even realise this had happened until later when I left Vrndavana and thought about the things that had happened to me. The things I did were definately real and not planned at all. If I get too specific and someone was there at the time I might get recognised so I don't want to get into details right now about myself but I would love to hear about the experiences of other devotees. unsure.gif

It is courageous to record such things publicly
although there is a paucity of remarkable information in your post.
Some people like to have such information. It may tend to increase
the respect they have for you as a Full Member of a forum such as this.

Sometimes a person's spiritual "C.V." may appear rather disjointed
if those mystical experiences which were major drivers in their lives
are not recorded also. (Interestingly, the more spiritually inclined you are the more likely this will be the case).

People who hold secret their mystical experiences and still maintain
association in spiritual groups walk a bizzare tightrope. It will not attract any applause for no-one will see the tightrope act. However if you fail,
you will be boo-ed. Remarkable but true ......
Madhava - Thu, 12 Aug 2004 17:12:41 +0530
I do not believe it is applauses the sAdhaka is after.
Talasiga - Thu, 12 Aug 2004 17:27:52 +0530
QUOTE (Madhava @ Aug 12 2004, 11:42 AM)
I do not believe it is applauses the sAdhaka is after.

If the sAdhaka is after something,
then the sAdhaka wants something.


If the sAdhaka does not care for applause
then the sAdhaka may not care for the injunctions.
The sAdhaka may share his or her mystic experiences with others
and be boo-ed for doing this.

So it is also with those who wear scholarship on their sleeve.
Madhava - Thu, 12 Aug 2004 17:31:56 +0530
The sAdhaka does, however,
care for the attainment
of his cherished objective
over anything and everything...
and so he cares for related injunctions.

Therefore it so happens, that
he reveals not such dear experiences
even at the risk of being boo-ed
for he cares not for those
who would boo
for their feeble blessing
would add up to little in the end.

I believe the recommendation to not do such
was clearly expressed by the mahAjans;
But of course, that is only for those
who are after the Gaudiya gold.
Talasiga - Thu, 12 Aug 2004 17:40:59 +0530
QUOTE (anuraag @ Aug 11 2004, 06:35 PM)
gopanIyaM prayatnena
yathA ratna-karaNDakam |
kasyacin naiva vaktavyaM
kula-strI-surataM yathA ||


(Hatha-yoga-pradipika 2.9)

With great effort, keep all these devotional emotions
hidden like a chest of precious stones. rolleyes.gif
Do not talk about them to anyone, whistling.gif
just as a high-class lady would not talk about
her intimate amorous experience to others. blush.gif


Jaya Sri Radhey!

Strengthen the disguise
Pretend to be an atheist
Knowing not the Lover .....
Jagat - Thu, 12 Aug 2004 18:59:36 +0530
I feel somewhat sympathetic to Talasiga's remarks here.

I am a little uncomfortable with my translation "pride's wind" because the original does not modify the wind at all. There may be various kinds of wind--"booing" being one.

But the desire to confirm one's personal experiences with sajatiya sanga seems to be a perfectly natural and positive thing. The question is whether a public forum is the place to do that. "nA kohibo jathA tathA" means "not anywhere and everywhere."

Poetry and literature are another thing. I think that certain literary forms permit personal revelation by divorcing them somewhat from the personal. The best poetry universalizes the personal, even though it may have very specific personal elements. Bad poetry is, of course, the failure to achieve this.

In a sense we should be flattered that Gopidust has as much innocent confidence in us as she does. On the other hand, the warning to be careful is one that should not be neglected.
Kishalaya - Thu, 12 Aug 2004 19:26:19 +0530
QUOTE (gopidust @ Aug 11 2004, 10:21 PM)
I would love to hear about the experiences of other devotees. unsure.gif

Sorry to interrupt, but the kind of replies to the original post should be reason enough not to divulge such secrets in public.

standard apologies attached tongue.gif
gopidust - Thu, 12 Aug 2004 21:19:16 +0530
unsure.gif I spoke with one devotee in here and got a realization so here I go, I hope Srila Prabhupada will forgive me if I am wrong.

Anyway when I was in Vrindavan Krishna or Radharani made arrangements so that while touring places of Krishna's pastimes I got very angry at Krishna and only wanted to take shelter of Radharani. At one point I said, "Who wants to see the places of Krishna's pastimes (separate from Radharani and Krishna's pastimes)and at another place I even yelled at the top of my lungs for all to hear how angry I was at Krishna! Somehow I was in a totally different mood than my usual one and the arrangements were made by Krishna I thought at the time. I felt like I was in my eternal rasa as a servant of Radharani and not Krishna directly. And I still feel that way now only now I won't forget it when I leave Vrindavan.

I hope my saying this does not encourage sahajiyaism. But what I feel is so real feeling to me I can't help but talk about it to someone.
Jagat - Thu, 12 Aug 2004 22:21:14 +0530
Gopidust,

Please drop your Sahajiya fear,
You are one of Radha's gan, my dear.
Be proud. You can thumb your nose
At all who say, "This door is closed."

We want some of your gopi dust,
On this path, gopi dust's a must.
Take sweet refuge in a rasik sage;
for you, Iskcon will prove but a cage.
Rasaraja dasa - Thu, 12 Aug 2004 22:39:50 +0530
Dandavats. All glories to the Vaisnavas.

Why the fear of turning into a “sahajiya”? Feeling emotions connected to your eternal relationship with your Svamini shouldn’t be a source of guilt or conflict. Again I think you need to understand what is and, most importantly, what isn't sahajiya.

Speaking about your emotions and letting them show in public may lead you to difficulty with others. Most here are trusting and will not judge you for such expressions but I am afraid that in ISKCON and most Mathas such expressions would not be encouraged.

All in all this should be something that is confidential. Share it with those that are dear to your heart and of course with your Guru so that such sentiments can be properly cultivated. I found Srila Ananta dasa Babaji’s analogy of the stam engine to be very poetic and practical.

The best way for you to understand and cultivate such emotions and longings is with the help of a Guru who can help you understand such feelings correctly and ensure that you are carefully cultivating your aspirations in a correct way.

This is where you will most likely be at a loss in ISKCON. Not that no one in ISKCON may experience such symptoms or be able to guide you in such a respect but due to the climate and mood of the institution it will be extremely hard to find someone willing to do so as it leaves them open to much criticism.

Aspiring to serve the Vaisnavas,
Rasaraja dasa
gopidust - Fri, 13 Aug 2004 02:05:16 +0530
blush.gifI am constantly thinking now I am a manjari and will keep this feeling to myself. Noone here knows me and I won't tell anybody I know in person. I don't see why I need to do anything differently than I'm doing already so I'm not in a rush to go find a brijabasi guru. Is Radharani the guru in Vrndavana I seem to remember hearing that somewhere?
As far as gopi gan or whatever not this girl biggrin.gif
Madhava - Fri, 13 Aug 2004 02:53:08 +0530
Gopi gan (gaNa) means a group of gopis. If you're a manjari, you'll have your own gopi-gan, a group of manjaris you spend time with rendering service.
Madhava - Fri, 13 Aug 2004 02:55:42 +0530
Commenting on the topic of the thread, I should note that factually experiencing svarUpa, as in svarUpAveza, as it's often called, is more than getting a glimpse into the mood; svarUpAveza, absorption in svarUpa during smaraNa, is a state of factual perception of the lIlA, with participation in the services depending on the degree of the purity of the heart and the greed for serivce.
Malatilata - Fri, 13 Aug 2004 03:50:44 +0530
QUOTE (gopidust @ Aug 12 2004, 03:49 PM)

Anyway when I was in Vrindavan Krishna or Radharani made arrangements so that while touring places of Krishna's pastimes I got very angry at Krishna and only wanted to take shelter of Radharani.

Sometimes the manjaris might show anger towards Krishna, if Krishna has hurt Radha's feelings, and Radha is also angry at Him. But generally the manjaris love Krishna very much, because He is so dear to their dearest Radha.

Sometimes when Radha is angry at Krishna, Krishna comes to the manjaris to ask their help and advice.

Srila Raghunatha dasa Gosvami prays in his manjari-svarupa:

"Once Mukunda flatters me in private and cries out: 'Alas! Alas!', asking me to help Him untie the knot of Radha's causeless pique, so for His sake I go and fall at Gandharva's lotusfeet. When will harsh Lalita cast crooked glances at me and rebuke me out of loving cruelty?"

From the commentary of Sri Ananta dasa Babaji: "...Tulasi's (Srila Raghunatha dasa) heart melts of compassion when she sees Krishna in this miserable condition; after all, as she is made out of pure love for the Divine Couple, how could she tolerate seeing Her Svamini's (Radha's) Prananatha suffering like that?

Tulasi consoles Syamasundara and goes to Svamini, falling at Her feet and telling Her of Nagara's misery and agitation. Desiring Gandharva's contentment, she says: 'Oh Isvari! Be pleased! Give up Your causeless pique! Your Nagara Mani, who is dearer to You than millions of life airs, is so anxiously praying at the feet of wretched maidservants like us, I can't tolerate the sight anymore!..."

(Sva Sankalpa Prakasa Stotram, verse 3)

Those who desire to become manjaris, serve Krishna to have their desire fulfilled:

"O Mind! Eagerly worship Sri Giridhari in Vraja, so that He will be so kind to remove the wickedness of a cheater like me, giving me the splendid nectar of conjugal love of God and engage me in the loving service of Sri Gandharva (Radha)!"

(Sri Manah Siksa, verse 8)
Jagat - Fri, 13 Aug 2004 05:26:02 +0530
Then why do you want oh so much to share--
to find friends who have tasted Vraja bhav,
a friend perhaps already living there,
who has the very things you'd like to have?

We don't just want to be, we would belong
to a great manjari bouquet, a group
that with one voice in joy sings this one song--
"We serve Radhé as dasi-das of Rup."
Rasaraja dasa - Fri, 13 Aug 2004 05:48:20 +0530
QUOTE (gopidust @ Aug 12 2004, 12:35 PM)
blush.gifI am constantly thinking now I am a manjari and will keep this feeling to myself. Noone here knows me and I won't tell anybody I know in person. I don't see why I need to do anything differently than I'm doing already so I'm not in a rush to go find a brijabasi guru. Is Radharani the guru in Vrndavana I seem to remember hearing that somewhere?
As far as gopi gan or whatever not this girl biggrin.gif

Dandavats. All glories to the Vaisnavas.

You have tasted the honey that has escaped to the outside of the jar. Keep that taste close to your heart and never forget it's sweetness. It will drive you to develop your aspirations and seek the shelter of a Guru who can so gently remove the honey jar's cap giving you complete access if you so dare.

Aspiring to serve the Vaisnavas,
Rasaraja dasa
gopidust - Fri, 13 Aug 2004 05:53:41 +0530
blush.gif I am embarassed my lack of knowledge is showing here. Anyway I can only claim to have gotten a glimpse of something it is true. I wanted to hear what others here have experienced but if you say anything prepare to be embarassed as I have been. blush.gif
Rasaraja dasa - Fri, 13 Aug 2004 06:07:37 +0530
QUOTE (gopidust @ Aug 12 2004, 04:23 PM)
blush.gif I am embarassed my lack of knowledge is showing here. Anyway I can only claim to have gotten a glimpse of something it is true. I wanted to hear what others here have experienced but if you say anything prepare to be embarassed as I have been. blush.gif

Dandavats. All glories to the Vaisnavas.

There is no need to be embarrassed. What you tasted was a unique and cherished gift from Sri Radhika. Our hope is that you understand how unique and cherished such a taste is and that you cultivate your desires to one day again have that taste and associate with those that will encourage such a desire. It is by the grace of the Vaisnavas, Gauranga and Sri Radhika that you will continue to receive these glimpses and one day, with the help of Guru and the Vaisnavas, cultivate your heart as such that such a taste will be absorbed in your heart and will forever be your goal.

Aspiring to serve the Vaisnavas,
Rasaraja dasa
Jagat - Fri, 13 Aug 2004 06:14:32 +0530
There is no shame if you have come to learn.
But know: each verse I quote, in ev'ry line,
are tears I had to pay out just to earn
the right to say: These holy words are mine!
Oxen Power - Fri, 13 Aug 2004 07:19:25 +0530
Dandavats,

Well I had a experience in awe and reverence, some sort of kundalini thing, I think. At the time I was into monism, Ramana Maharshi, UG Krishnamurti, etc. I have told a few people, it is sorta hard not to want to share. At the same time people will think you're crazy, so best only to tell close friends. As I read earlier, keep it in your heart.

The main thing is I find out the personal side of the Lord is much kinder than the
impersonal ''light,'' losing ego, etc. I believe in SB. It mentions the passive awe
and reverence state is turya, and the more advanced rasa where this is exchange
of love between the jiva and Krishna is turyatitah..... So anyways, I thank Krishna
for bringing me out of Mayavadi. That was just too dry and boring that impersonalism. I guess its ok I shared that here since we are all devotees, for the most part I think I will keep it quiet and hidden in my heart from here on out......

HARE KRISHNA !
Madanmohan das - Fri, 13 Aug 2004 21:26:13 +0530
pranam to all.
I can't find the referance just now but somewhere in a foot note of the Gita press Bhagavat Puran there is a quote to the effect that "A virtue uttered is avirtue lost". When I find the sanskrt I'll post it.
Satyabhama - Mon, 16 Aug 2004 21:30:10 +0530
That's an interesting way to look at Radha-dasyam, as a counter-movement for those frustrated with God and bored with the void

-----

Wow had thought of being angry with Radha, also had thought of being angry with Krishna... but never thought of it in this way ever! Very interesting!
gopidust - Tue, 17 Aug 2004 01:34:36 +0530
blush.gif Ok I can explain what happened to me better now. I was in Vrndavana and the rest of the devotees were of course happy seeing Krishna's places of pastimes but I did not. I was in anxiety to see Radharani's. But Krishna put me in HIS place of pastimes. So I HATED Krishna. I'm sorry but I did. I yelled out loud how angry I was at Krishna for keeping me in His places of pastimes and keeping me from going to Radharani's place and I started to cry. I acted worse than this but if I say exactly what I did after this and someone was there they might remember me by what I did and figure out who I am but it was bad. But I did not consciously do it. I was in 100% total anxiety to see the places of Radharani's pastimes and that was all I wanted to do.
Madhava - Tue, 17 Aug 2004 01:50:07 +0530
Had you understood Krishna's thoughts of Radha in all those places, you might have taken a different approach. The two go hand in hand, you know.
gopidust - Tue, 17 Aug 2004 02:13:00 +0530
I LOVE Radharani!
Madhava - Tue, 17 Aug 2004 02:41:50 +0530
She loves Krishna. Do you love her heart's innermost feelings, considering them as you express your love?
Satyabhama - Tue, 17 Aug 2004 02:48:57 +0530
I can understand being angry with Krishna, if you are thinking that He has slighted Radharani in some way by not showing up for a planned meeting, etc. However, let it be superficial anger, because Krishna always loves Radharani, no matter what. Certainly, He will not forsake Her at any time. Krishna is the Lord of the heart of the Lady of your heart, Radha, so how can you stay angry with Him? smile.gif
gopidust - Tue, 17 Aug 2004 06:51:32 +0530
Why am I angry at Krishna? Because they made fun of me in Vrndavana that's why when I cried. And it was Krishna's camp that did it. Radharani is my guru and I will do whatever she says in regards to serving Krishna.
There is more to the story but again I don't want to say too much for fear of who I am being discovered.