Google
Web         Gaudiya Discussions
Gaudiya Discussions Archive » HEALTH, TRAVEL, ENVIRONMENT
Health, travel, environment and other related topics. Tips and tricks for keeping your body in shape for spiritual life. Taking care of your health while traveling in India.

Cow-slaughter/non-veg contamination of food - Limits of purity



nabadip - Tue, 30 Dec 2003 22:55:23 +0530
Jai Nitai
I would like to understand what is the ethical, theological etc background for vaishnavas why we should not eat anything contaminated with non-veg ingredients. Of course, I avoid any possible connection, but it is so difficult that you can practically forget 100% purity, unless you allow for a certain grey-zone. Even if you eat only prasad made from scratch, you are likely to have some ingredient that has come in touch with non-veg substances, esp if you include also the process of cultivation (animal ingredients in fertilizers used). If you buy flour to make bread, there are anti-clumping ingredients made of cow-bone. Even if you buy organic wheat, it is likely to have been grown with some kind of fish-bone ingredient in the fertilizer etc.

Cow bone is not only in the food, it's also in the paper we use, in the clothes, in colour, in everything.

So the ethical questions are of importance:

Is it that we are participating in the slaughter process, that such food should or could not be offered to the Lord, that it is impure, or which other consideration?

Another reason why I am asking is that the societies we live in are dependent on the system of cow slaughter. Milk products would have to be forbidden for us too, only Vegan life-style would be an option. Even then we continue to implicitely support the agri-policy of cow-slaughter. If you look thoroughly at how the agri-business works and how our societies are dependent on the policies operating in it, we cannot close our eyes from the fact that we are also in the net of its interdependences.
Jai Nitai
Advaitadas - Tue, 30 Dec 2003 23:37:17 +0530
This is a battle we cannot win. sad.gif We can only do the best we can. We also kill so many germs by breathing in and smash so many small creatures on the ground as we walk. It is the intention of ahimsa that counts. Furthermore,

kaler dosha nidhe rajan asti hyeko mahad guna
kirtanad eva krishnasya sarva svartho'bhilabhyate
(Bhag.)

"In the ocean of faults that is the age of Kali there is but one great virtue - simply by Krishna Kirtan one attains all welfare."
nabadip - Wed, 31 Dec 2003 01:07:15 +0530
You said in another thread that it (non-veg) is forbidden for a vaishnava. What is the understanding behind the Verbot? Just ahimsa, nothing else?

Where is the limit?

How about wearing leather shoes?
Advaitadas - Wed, 31 Dec 2003 02:04:01 +0530
QUOTE(nabadip @ Dec 30 2003, 07:37 PM)
You said in another thread that it (non-veg) is forbidden for a vaishnava. What is the understanding behind the Verbot? Just ahimsa, nothing else?

Where is the limit?

How about wearing leather shoes?


My Gurudeva called non veg food 'ugra ahara', which means violent, cruel food, and he called veg food 'ahara suddhi', pure food. This speaks for itself.

I have a pair of rubber boots, a pair of shoes with laces made of artificial stuff and a pair of cloth summer shoes.